Lexington’s Greatest Tables
5 restaurants listedGet the complete Lexington dining guide.
We email you when a table worth booking opens in Lexington — new openings and editor picks, free.
$ under $40 · $$ $40–$80 · $$$ $80–$150 · $$$$ $150+ per person
Best for First Date in Lexington
Best for Business Dinner in Lexington
The Top 5 Lexington Restaurants
Holly Hill Inn
Holly Hill Inn holds an 1839 Greek Revival farmhouse on North Winter Street in Midway, a fifteen-minute drive west of downtown Lexington and a five-minute walk from the Midway Station Railroad on the small-town square. Ouita Michel and her husband Chris purchased the property in 2000 after a chance meeting with Bob Rouse, whose family had owned the Holly Hill homestead for generations, and opened their fine-dining restaurant in 2001 — the room has now held the Bluegrass fine-dining seat for a full quarter century. The dining floor sprawls across three connected period rooms on the ground floor: a front parlour with original pine floors and a working fireplace, a central dining room with twelve-foot ceilings and tall casement windows facing the rear paddock, and a back room that opens onto a stone-paved terrace where summer tasting-menu evenings spill outdoors under string lights and the Bluegrass dusk.
Dudley's on Short
Dudley's on Short occupies a brick courtyard townhouse on West Short Street at the corner of North Mill, two blocks north of the Lexington Convention Center and three blocks west of Rupp Arena, and has poured modern American cuisine from the same Bluegrass family ownership since 1981. The dining-room footprint runs across four distinct rooms on two floors: a casual front bar room with high tables and a marble-topped bar pouring north of forty bourbons by the glass, a more formal main dining room with white linens and dim filament pendants over leather banquettes, an upstairs private dining suite that books four-tops through twenty covers for birthday and corporate dinners, and a brick-paved rear courtyard that opens for outdoor dining seven months of the year under a wisteria-shaded pergola.
Jeff Ruby's Steakhouse
Jeff Ruby's Steakhouse holds the ground-floor corner of West Vine Street and Mill in downtown Lexington, a one-block walk from the Lexington Convention Center and a three-block walk from Rupp Arena, and has run as the Lexington flagship of the Cincinnati-based Jeff Ruby Culinary Entertainment group since opening in 2019. The dining floor sprawls across two large connected rooms plus the celebrated Gatsby private dining room: the main floor reads as the glitz-and-glamour of the gilded age made unmistakably Lexington — Art Deco pendants and starburst chandeliers over deep leather booths, gold-leaf finishes on the Italian marble bar that runs the southern length of the room, mahogany cigar-room paneling on the eastern wall, and the signature Gatsby Room behind the kitchen pass where the carpet on the floor was originally part of the set for Baz Luhrmann's Great Gatsby film with Leonardo DiCaprio.
Tony’s of Lexington
Tony's of Lexington holds the ground-floor corner of West Main Street and Patterson at The Square retail-and-residential complex directly across from Rupp Arena and the Lexington Convention Center, and has run as proprietor Tony Ricci's Lexington flagship since opening. The dining-room footprint runs across a single large main floor with a mezzanine private dining loft above the sushi bar: the main floor reads as a deliberate urban-chic blend of Southern hospitality and Manhattan steakhouse — high coffered ceilings with industrial pendants, deep leather booths along the eastern wall, white linens and gold-and-mahogany finishes across the central four-top floor, and the dramatic central feature wall of back-lit wine cubbies that holds about eight hundred labels visible from every table on the floor. The marble bar runs the southern length of the room and pours a hundred-plus-bourbon programme alongside a thirty-cocktail signature menu.
Coles 735 Main
Coles 735 Main holds a converted single-storey cottage on East Main Street in the Bell Court neighbourhood, two miles east of The Square in downtown Lexington and one block from the Henry Clay Estate at Ashland on Sycamore Road. Lexington-native chef and proprietor Cole Arimes opened the room in 2012 and has run it as a single coherent chef-driven dining floor for fourteen years now — the giveaway that a chef-driven Kentucky room is genuinely held rather than rented. The dining floor seats about sixty across a single low-lit room with French-countryside-inspired decor — exposed limestone walls salvaged from the original cottage frame, warm filament pendants over each white-linen-set table, leather banquettes along the western wall, a small marble-topped front bar that pours about thirty signature cocktails, and a single chef's table at the back of the floor that books four-tops with a view directly into the working kitchen line.
Dining in Lexington
The Dining Culture
Lexington's dining culture runs on three intersecting traditions — the Bluegrass farm-to-fork sourcing that Holly Hill Inn and Coles 735 Main have refined into chef-driven fine dining over two decades, the bourbon-belt steakhouse format that Jeff Ruby's and Tony's have built into Manhattan-grade urban-chic statement rooms around The Square, and the modern American institutional cooking that Dudley's on Short has held continuously from West Short Street since 1981. The horse-industry money — Keeneland sales, the Kentucky Derby weekend at Churchill Downs ninety minutes west, the global thoroughbred clientele moving through the Bluegrass region year-round — keeps the upper end of the dining map well-funded and the booking discipline tight.
Best Neighbourhoods
Downtown Lexington — the walkable grid bounded by Vine, Main, Limestone and Broadway — holds the in-town fine-dining concentration. Dudley's on Short is on West Short Street between Mill and Broadway. Jeff Ruby's is on the corner of West Vine and Mill. Tony's of Lexington is on West Main facing Rupp Arena at The Square. Coles 735 Main sits two miles east in the Bell Court neighbourhood near the Henry Clay Estate. Holly Hill Inn is in the small Woodford County town of Midway, fifteen miles west of downtown along US 60 — the drive across the horse-country pastures is part of the evening's architecture.
Reservations & Practical Tips
Holly Hill Inn books four to six weeks ahead on weekends and ten to twelve weeks for the first weekend of May (Derby Week). Jeff Ruby's, Tony's and Dudley's book two to three weeks ahead on Keeneland race-meet weekends (the first three weekends of April and October), Kentucky basketball home Saturdays from November through March, and Derby Week. Coles 735 Main usually takes a week's notice except on Keeneland Saturdays. Bluegrass Airport (LEX) is a fifteen-minute drive from downtown, and Lyft and Uber both run reliably through the Lexington walking grid. The Hyatt Regency, the Lexington Marriott and the Holiday Inn at The Square sit within four blocks of all three downtown steakhouses.
Dress Code & Tipping
Holly Hill Inn and Jeff Ruby's are both smart — jackets welcomed at Holly Hill, recommended in Jeff Ruby's Gatsby Room. Dudley's, Tony's and Coles are all smart casual with collared shirts. Tipping in Kentucky runs the US standard 18–22% on the pre-tax total at fine-dining venues, and Derby Week and Keeneland race-meet weekends typically attract a 25% tip among regulars who want to hold their booking discipline for the next visit. Bourbon programmes run deep at all five — expect a sommelier or bar captain to walk a single-barrel or allocated-bourbon recommendation alongside the wine pairing at the request.